Client Alert
FINRA Arbitration Award with Punitive Damages in Favor of Retired Public Customer Who Was Overconcentrated in High Risk and Illiquid “Alternative Investments”
May 22, 2019
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) have finally ramped up enforcement on the sale of private stakes in companies. It is reported that more than 16 million households in the United States are investing directly in private companies. With one in eight households making direct investment in these high risk ventures, the financial fallout from investments gone bad is substantial. The impact of such private investments on the affected individuals can be devastating. In many instances, the individual investors do not see the danger that lurks because private companies do not have to make the same disclosures that public companies do.
In October 2018 Christopher Lonn proceeded to FINRA securities arbitration against Berthel Fisher & Company Financial Services, Inc. and its registered representative, Robert D’Agosta. Mr. Lonn’s client, Roy Manson, filed the claim in 2016 alleging, inter alia, that over a period of at least six years that Berthel Fisher and D’Agosta breached fiduciary duties owed to Mr. Manson and violated the anti-fraud provisions of the Arizona Securities Act. As Roy Manson approached retirement at the end of 2011, he rolled over his 401k account to the care of Berthel Fisher and D’Agosta. Contrary to Mr. Manson’s stated investment objectives and risk tolerance, Berthel Fisher and D’Agosta solicited Mr. Manson to invest the vast majority of his retirement funds into numerous high-risk and illiquid private investments also known as “alternative investments.” D’Agosta misrepresented these high risk investments to Mr. Manson as safe and relatively low risk. One such “alternative investment” Mr. Manson also alleged that Berthel Fisher failed to properly supervise D’Agosta by failing to insure that Mr. Manson was provided with a prospectus for each private investment at the time of solicitation. To make matters worse, D’Agosta was also trading options without written authorization in another account that he managed for Mr. Manson. Berthel Fisher is based in Cedar Rapids, Iowa and D’Agosta operated his business out of remote office in Pennsylvania.
Following the extensive five day FINRA arbitration, the panel of three arbitrators found that Berthel Fisher and D’Agosta were jointly and severally liable to Mr. Manson for compensatory damages. In addition, the arbitration panel specifically found that Berthel Fisher and D’Agosta were liable for punitive damages in an amount equal to the compensatory damages due to Mr. Manson. The arbitration panel stated that the punitive damages were awarded for material misrepresentations and omissions by D’Agosta tantamount to fraud in the sale of securities.
For more information on this topic or other commercial litigation matters, please contact Mr. Lonn.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Christopher D. Lonn | Read Bio
About Jennings, Strouss & Salmon, P.L.C.
For over 75 years, Jennings Strouss has been dedicated to providing clients with strategic legal guidance to help them seize every opportunity. The firm is well-known for its rich heritage, commitment to community, and long-lasting relationships. We have a deep understanding of business and law. When you work with us, you’ll have a team of legal experts who are dedicated to your vision of success.
Through our offices in Phoenix, Peoria, and Tucson, Arizona, and Washington, D.C., we leverage resources both regionally and nationally to serve our expanding client base. Jennings Strouss is deeply rooted in each of our locations’ legal and business communities, and especially instrumental in helping shape the dynamic growth of Arizona and many of its institutions. The firm promotes a pragmatic, results-oriented approach, coupled with a healthy, well-managed, and friendly atmosphere of collaboration.
Our primary areas of practice include advertising and media law; agribusiness; automobile dealership law; bankruptcy, restructuring, and creditors’ rights; construction; corporate and securities; eminent domain and condemnation; employee benefits and pensions; energy; estate planning and probate; family law and domestic relations; finance; healthcare; insurance defense; intellectual property; labor and employment; legal ethics; litigation; medical malpractice; professional liability defense; real estate; surety and fidelity; and tax.
For additional information, please visit www.jsslaw.com and follow us on LinkedIn, Facebook, and Twitter.
The Law Firm Alliance

Read More
Contact Us
One East Washington Street, Suite 1900
Phoenix, AZ 85004-2554
P 602.262.5911 | F 602.495.2979
9051 West Kelton Lane, Suite 9
Peoria, AZ 85382-3533
P 623.878.2222 | F 623.878.1333
1760 E. River Road, Suite 230
Tucson, AZ 85718-5990
P 520.618.1050 | F 520.618.1070
1300 I Street NW, Suite 1120
Washington, D.C. 20005-3314
P 202.292.4738 | F 202.371.9025